Summary
The Cleveland Township Board held a regular meeting on September 10, 2024, during which significant concerns were raised regarding Segment 9 of the Sleeping Bear Heritage Trail. The board voted unanimously to rescind their previous support for this segment due to environmental impacts and fiscal concerns. Public comments reflected a deeply divided opinion on the trail, with some advocating for alternatives considering ecological impacts, while others supported the trail for safety and recreational benefits.
Public Comments
Multiple community members voiced their opinions during the public comments segment:
- **Kim Hayes** mentioned her experience as a conservation professional, urging the board to oppose Segment 9 due to significant environmental impact concerns. She requested exploration of alternative routes.
- **Gwen Allgier** expressed skepticism about the project’s community acceptance and shared concerns about the destruction of beech trees.
- **Marian Sutter** supported Segment 9, emphasizing the benefits of the trail for cyclists.
- **David Tabolt** criticized opposition to the trail, claiming that public support is significant and the environmental concerns exaggerated.
- **Scott Martin** conveyed personal concerns regarding property rights and the potential implications of the project on his property.
- Other speakers expressed concerns regarding environmental effects, proper land use, and the handling of potential safety hazards related to trail access.
The board acknowledged a considerable volume of letters and emails opposing the trail.
Infrastructure Projects
The most significant infrastructure topic discussed was Segment 9 of the Sleeping Bear Heritage Trail. The board members shared their perspectives, noting the need for a different route due to the environmental risks associated with the current proposed path. Ultimately, the board resolved:
- To rescind its September 10, 2019 resolution in support of Segment 9, expressing opposition based on fiscal irresponsibility and environmental impact concerns.
- A motion was made by Tim Stein and seconded by Todd Nowak to formalize this opposition, with all members voting in favor.
Other Business
- Accepted the Treasurer’s Report with a balance of $405,627.64.
- Approved the L-4029 Tax Rate Request for necessary operating and road maintenance milages.
- Provided an update on the Little Traverse Lake Rd East End Project, indicating progress toward paving.
Financial Summary
- Treasurer’s Report as of August 31, 2024, reported a beginning balance of $398,647.25, revenue of $21,926.25, and disbursements of $14,945.86 leading to an ending balance of $405,627.64.
- The approval of operating mileage of 0.5402 and fire service mileage of 2.50 was discussed for levying in December.
Action Items
- Follow-up on the implications of opposing Segment 9 of the Sleeping Bear Heritage Trail was assigned to the board members.
- The planning commission is tasked with prioritizing goals and action steps regarding the master plan.
- Maintenance issues, including tree removal at the boat launch area, to be addressed.
- Ongoing communication regarding public concerns toward the Segment 9 trail project will be handled by board members as further correspondence arises.