Leelanau Planning Commission | Public Comment Received

The proposed construction of a cellular tower near the intersection of Kitchen and Garthe Roads in Leelanau Township has sparked significant debate among residents. Jan Rygwelski supports the tower, emphasizing the dire need for improved cellular coverage in the area. Having lived in the township for nearly nine years, Rygwelski highlights the current reliance on VOIP for phone service, which becomes unavailable during internet outages. The lack of reliable cell service poses a serious risk, particularly for emergency situations, as residents must drive to town to access a signal. Rygwelski argues that the proposed tower is essential for the safety of both residents and summer visitors, who may require immediate medical assistance.

On the other hand, Paris Morse vehemently opposes the tower, citing multiple violations of Leelanau Township Zoning Ordinances and the Master Plan. Morse points out that the proposed 200-foot tower exceeds the height limits set by the ordinances and would disrupt the scenic ridgeline and wetlands. Additionally, Morse questions the tower's effectiveness, noting that a similar tower at the Government Center has not provided any cell service. The county's plan to provide fiber internet to all residences by the end of the year is presented as an alternative solution that would negate the need for the tower. Morse also criticizes the application for misleading information and lack of necessary studies, such as a wetland delineation report and an FAA statement regarding lighting requirements.

The debate over the proposed cellular tower underscores a broader tension between the need for improved communication infrastructure and the desire to preserve the community's character and environmental integrity. While Rygwelski's support is driven by safety concerns, Morse's opposition is rooted in adherence to local regulations and the potential negative impacts on the landscape. The Planning Commission faces a challenging decision, balancing the immediate needs of residents with long-term community values and legal compliance.